St. Paul's United Methodist Church, Ithaca

Saint Paul’s United Methodist Church is a historic place of worship with roots dating back to 1790 when Methodist meetings were first held in a small cabin in Dewitt Park. Officially incorporated in 1819, the Methodist Society constructed its first wooden church in 1820 on land donated by General Simon Dewitt. Over the years, the growing congregation experienced significant revivals and expansions, eventually outgrowing its initial structures.

By 1907, the cornerstone of the present church building was laid, with most of the construction completed in 1908. The church was formally dedicated in January 1909, marking the culmination of decades of growth and community service.

The church's architecture and features are notable for their beauty and craftsmanship. Among its treasures are two stunning stained glass windows, "The Ascension" and "The Light of the World," which are believed to be Tiffany creations, though this has not been confirmed. These windows add a sense of reverence and artistry to the sanctuary, complementing the rich historical legacy of the building.

In 1952, an education wing was added, seamlessly blending with the original structure thanks to the careful reuse of stone from the north side of the church. The new wing included a gymnasium on the second floor, demonstrating the church’s commitment to serving both spiritual and practical needs.

Saint Paul’s also boasts a remarkable musical heritage, highlighted by the installation of a Pels Organ in 1957. Built in the Netherlands, the organ features four manuals, pedals, 53 stops, and 51 ranks of pipes, creating a powerful and resonant sound for worship and special events.